Grill't New Castle
Grill't Logo

Grill't

@

5.02865 reviews

Grill't serves flavorful char-flamed foods and made-from-scratch sides. This welcoming spot in New Castle offers creative American cuisine that brings comfort and satisfaction. It’s a popular choice for lunch and dinner with a casual vibe and an easygoing atmosphere.

The restaurant features accessible seating and a relaxed ambience. Food lovers come here for a genuine barbecue experience, highlighted by their signature dishes like the coal-smoked brisket and fried pickles. Prices are budget-friendly, making it easy to enjoy great meals without breaking the bank.

Grill't takes pride in local specialties, blending traditional techniques with a bit of flair. Whether dining solo or with a group, guests find a diverse menu filled with options for everyone. There's a focus on quality ingredients, ensuring every plate is satisfying and flavorful.

From the first bite, it’s clear that Grill't aims to impress. This place captures the essence of American barbecue while remaining friendly and approachable. Don’t miss their unique sauces and delightful sides, crafted to complete your meal experience.

About

Located at 535 N Memorial Dr, Grill't is more than just a restaurant. It’s a community hub in New Castle, serving up hearty meals with a heartwarming touch. The staff welcomes everyone with smiles and southern hospitality, making it an inviting space to dine with friends and family.

Grill't began with a passion for barbecue and a desire to create memorable dining experiences. The owners crafted a menu that showcases local flavors, ensuring that each dish reflects the area’s culinary heritage. All dishes are made from scratch, which adds a personal touch to every meal.

The restaurant has become known for its signature dishes and friendly service. Guests feel right at home, whether they dine in or opt for takeout. Grill't often hosts community events, engaging locals and creating bonds over shared meals. This commitment to service and quality food keeps folks coming back.

The cozy setting features accessible seating and a relaxed vibe. With a focus on bringing people together, Grill't fosters a sense of family among staff and patrons alike. It’s about savoring delicious food in a welcoming environment, where everyone feels valued and appreciated.

Get in Touch

535 N Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 16:00-19:00
  • Wednesday 16:00-19:00
  • Thursday 16:00-19:00
  • Friday 16:00-20:00
  • Saturday 16:00-20:00
  • Sunday 16:00-19:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"When we arrived they came out and greeted us. Then as the menu conversation started. So helpful with helping us decide. The gentleman brought out stuff for us to taste. It was so mouthwatering. We placed our order. Fresh sweet tea, pulled pork sandwich with green beans. My hubby ordered heap Mac loaded with Brisket and side of baked beans ! It was EXCELLENT FOOD & SERVICE "

- Martin D.

"Great spot with outstanding food. The meats are great and perfectly Smokey. This restaurant has a great take on sweet and spicy BBQ sauce, almost like a glaze. I tried the brisket and ribs, along with sides like fries, Mac n cheese, green beans, and the baked beans. The sides could be better, but the staff and service were extremely polite and helpful. They offered free samples of the food and were Very prompt with service. Grill't is a hidden gem, hole-in-the-wall barbecue joint. Definitely the best BBQ I've had in Indiana."

- Tim B.

"The food here is awesome. Served just like how you want bbq. Sauced heavy and super flavorful. The ladies at the front are amazing. They are burst of life and seem happy to be serving you their great food. Loved interacting with them. Rib tips were unreal. Great sweet tea as well!"

- Justin R.

""The service here is next level! When we arrived, they immediately greeted us and started a helpful conversation about the menu. The gentleman went above and beyond, bringing out stuff for us to taste--it was so mouthwatering! We ordered the fresh sweet tea and a pulled pork sandwich with green beans. My hubby got the Heap Mac loaded with Brisket and baked beans. It was EXCELLENT FOOD & SERVICE ."

- Jordan M.

"May 10th, 2025 I want to recognize Anthony and the staff at grill't today (really every day)! I sent them a message on Facebook Messenger a few weeks ago asking if they ever opened up earlier than the normal hours for people. I explained to them that our oldest son was graduating from Ivy Tech on May 10th and the ceremony was going to be held at the New Castle field house. We wanted to celebrate Saijin with grill'ts great barbecue and they were more than happy to oblige. We was able to reserve the entire restaurant for a private event and not only that, we were able to request a certain side that's not always available (Saijin's favorite...Spuds) and Anthony even gifted Saijin a gift card to come back again! They have AMAZING food and even better service and they deserve to be recognized. Please go try their food if you've never been. You won't be disappointed! Today (March 29th, 2025) we picked up a preorder of Grill't's catered food! We ordered some pork belly burnt ends, green beans, collard greens, and the cheesy spuds. Anthony made EVERYTHING well above our expectations. If you like barbecue, go to Grill't and check them out. They make delicious food and they are the friendliest people. Grill't has AMAZING food and the staff is so nice and friendly. We definitely recommend eating there. We tried the fried pickles for the first time today and they were delicious. Debbie definitely makes them the best. Look at that breading! "

- Angela J.

"My grandma my son and I went to have lunch today and had some of the absolute BEST pulled pork and pulled chicken sandwiches!!! Had Mac n cheese n fries for our sides and those were great as well. The house made each there is also AMAZING!!!! Highly recommend this business. The staff there as well are very warm and welcoming, good energy all around! Go get your food to go or dine in "

- ivee s.

""I absolutely loved this experience! It's fantastic to see such a good BBQ place in my hometown. The service was warm and welcoming, and though they were sold out of a few things, that's a great sign that their food is popular and high quality! They proactively suggested alternatives. I loved the food, and highly recommend visiting this popular local BBQ spot--it's worth the trip!""

- Blake P.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Grill't offers an authentic barbecue experience you won’t want to miss. The menu is filled with a variety of dishes, perfect for meat lovers. The pulled pork sandwich and signature brisket have become favorites among regulars, earning rave reviews for their rich flavors and tender textures.

Consider visiting during lunch or dinner. The ambiance is inviting, making it a great spot for a casual meal or gathering with friends. The staff is known for their warm hospitality, often providing free samples to help diners make their choices.

For a unique twist on traditional barbecue, try the Heap of Mac Loaded, a crowd-pleaser packed with flavor. Combine that with seasoned fries or baked beans, and you have the perfect meal. The sides are worth exploring, with options like country pot collard greens that elevate any dish.

Be sure to check for special offerings and seasonal menu items. The restaurant embraces creativity, making each visit a little different. Reservations are often accepted, especially during busy times, ensuring you have a seat at the table. Don't miss this gem in New Castle!

Most Liked things

The food quality at Grill't is exceptional. Guests rave about the coal-smoked brisket and pulled pork. Both dishes showcase the distinct smoky flavors of barbecue.

Service is another highlight. Staff members are friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming environment for diners. The positive energy enhances the overall experience.

The atmosphere is also a plus. With its relaxed vibe and community feel, Grill't is ideal for gatherings. Plus, the accessible seating ensures everyone can enjoy a meal together.

Fried pickles and various sides prove to be crowd favorites, providing great options for sharing. This sense of community and shared meals really enhances each visit.

Most Disliked things

While most visitors enjoy their meals, some feel the sides could be improved. A few reviews mention that certain options may lack creativity or seasoning, suggesting room for enhancement.

Another common point is the narrow operating hours. Some guests wish Grill't offered lunch services on days it remains closed, as they’d love to swing by for a midday barbecue fix.

Occasionally, diners experience longer wait times during peak hours, especially when the restaurant is busy. However, the attentive staff usually compensates by keeping everyone informed.

Despite these minor criticisms, most patrons are pleased and continue to praise the quality of food and service. Overall, any shortcomings do not overshadow the fulfilling dining experience.

FAQ

What types of dishes are served at Grill't?

Grill't offers flavorful char-flamed foods and creative American cuisine. Menu highlights include smoked barbecue, seasoned fries, and a variety of sides.

Is there a children's menu available?

Yes, Grill't provides a children's menu with options like chicken nuggets and hot dogs, making it a family-friendly spot.

Can I place a reservation at Grill't?

Yes, Grill't accepts reservations. It's a good idea to book ahead, especially during busy lunch and dinner hours.

What payment methods are accepted?

Grill't accepts credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments, ensuring convenience for all customers.

Is Grill't accessible for individuals with disabilities?

Yes, Grill't offers wheelchair-accessible entry, seating, and restrooms, making it inclusive for all guests.